Why Barefoot Shoes Bad
Introduction
Barefoot shoes have blown up in the past couple of years, touted as a solution to “natural movement,” healthier feet, and even prevention of injury. Companies sell them as a return to our evolutionary past, saying that classic cushioned shoes compromise foot muscles and throw off gait. Runners, gym enthusiasts, and even grocery shoppers are abandoning supportive sneakers for these ultra-thin, ultra-stretchy shoes but is the trend really as good as it appears?
The truth is, barefoot shoes aren’t for everyone, and for some, they might do more harm than good. In this article, “Why Barefoot Shoes Are Bad: The Hidden Risks of Minimalist Footwear,” we’ll explore the potential downsides, from increased injury risks to poor biomechanics and impracticality in daily life. If you’ve considered making the switch or already own a pair, it’s worth understanding the drawbacks before committing to this minimalist footwear trend. Let’s dive in.
Read our article What Are Wide And Regular Shoes?
What are Barefoot Shoes
Barefoot shoes, or minimalist footwear, attempt to replicate the barefoot walking experience with minimal protection from the ground. They are very thin, very flexible shoes with zero heel-to-toe drop, wide toe boxes to accommodate natural toe splay, and no arch support or cushioning, theoretically resulting in stronger foot muscles and a more natural gait.
They are intended to restore proper biomechanics by allowing the feet to move as nature dictated by supporters, but critics argue that modern lifestyles and floors make them impractical or even risky to wear for most individuals. Barefoot shoes are distinct from traditional shoes that offer support and shock absorption because they off-load the entire weight of impact management to the intrinsic structure of the foot, which may be aversive to individuals not being gradually conditioned to them.
Why Barefoot Shoes Bad
Barefoot shoes have their own dedicated following, but they’re not the magic bullet for all. Various individuals experience genuine issues with the adjustment process to this minimalist footwear, ranging from instant agony to chronic injury. Let’s dissect the most important reasons why barefoot shoes can be a bad idea for you.
Higher Risk of Overuse Injuries
One of the biggest concerns with barefoot shoes is their lack of cushioning. Unlike traditional shoes that absorb shock, minimalist footwear forces your feet, ankles, knees, and hips to handle all the impact. This can lead to stress fractures, tendonitis, and even chronic joint pain, especially if you’re active on hard surfaces like concrete. Without proper adaptation, the sudden switch can strain your Achilles tendon and plantar fascia, making everyday movement painful.
Lack of Safety and Support
Barefoot shoes mean stepping on every pebble, every crack, and every uneven ground with every footstep. Some like this extra sensory feedback, but some find it unpleasant or even dangerous, particularly on abrasive ground. The absence of arch support also worsens flat feet or overpronation, leading to instability and aches over the long term. People used to supportive footwear will feel like going back when they switch to barefoot footwear rather than moving forward.
A Challenging and Agonizing Transition Phase
Your feet slowly acclimatize to barefoot shoes, and not everyone survives without challenges. Some users complain of soreness, blisters, and fatigue in their muscles as their feet struggle to acclimatize to the new stresses. For users with already present foot complications, the process worsens problems instead of eliminating them. Worse still, some users persist with the discomfort believing that it is normal before they ultimately suffer from long-term damage.
Compromised Running and Walking Mechanics
Barefoot shoes promote a midfoot or forefoot strike, and it can be wonderful if your body is so inclined to do it naturally. But if you force the gait without correct alignment, you will end up with inefficient movement patterns and increased stress on your calves and feet. Some runners actually get slower or less stable by doing it, which completely negates the reason for trying it in the first place. Without formal coaching, you can end up substituting one issue for another.
Not Suitable for All Tasks
Whereas barefoot shoes are just fine for some light jogging around or even just walking around, they lack high-impact activities, professions, or environment. Basketball or tennis necessitates a need for lateral stability and shock absorption that minimalist shoes do not offer. Likewise, if you spend all day on your feet or have to deal with being in really cold temperatures, thin-soled shoes will leave you vulnerable to discomfort and open to being injured.
The Bottom Line
Barefoot shoes might seem like a natural and healthy choice, but they come with real risks. Without proper preparation, they can lead to pain, injuries, and frustration. If you’re considering them, it’s wise to consult a podiatrist or movement specialist first. For many people, a balanced approach mixing minimalist footwear with supportive shoes might be the smarter way to go.
Read our article What Are Non-Marking Shoes?
How to Make Barefoot Shoes More Comfortable
Transitioning to barefoot shoes is not an agonizing experience. With proper maintenance, you’ll enjoy all the advantages of minimalist shoes without the usual grievances. Here’s how to ease into it and keep your feet smiling.
Build Up Gradually
Your feet take time to acclimatize to the stress of barefoot shoes. Start with them for a short 30-60 minutes a day for light activity such as walking around the house. Gradually add on the wear time by 10-15% each week as your feet become accustomed. This gradual gain avoids overuse trauma and enables your tendons, muscles, and ligaments to condition appropriately.
Strengthen Your Feet
Before the full-time barefoot shoe transition, condition your feet with directed exercise. Try toe spreads, calf raises, and short barefoot walking over uneven ground. Foot exercises like toeing up marbles or rolling your feet using a foot roller can help strengthen the small stabilizing muscles required by minimalist shoes. The stronger your feet are, the less painful the transition will be.
Choose the Perfect Pair
All barefoot shoes are not created equal. Be sure to find:
- A very flexible sole that will allow flex in every direction
- A toe box that is wide enough so it won’t crush your toes
- Zero drop from the heel to the toe
- Some but minimal protection for your desired activity
Consider starting with a “transitional” model that offers slightly more protection than true barefoot shoes if you’re coming from traditional footwear.
Improve Your Walking and Running Form
Barefoot shoes reward proper biomechanics. Focus on:
- Shorter strides to reduce impact
- Landing with a midfoot or forefoot strike
- Keeping your steps light and quiet
- Engaging your core for better posture
Recording yourself running or walking can identify form issues that might cause discomfort.
Wear Them on the Right Surfaces
Start by wearing your barefoot shoes on forgiving surfaces like grass, dirt trails, or padded tracks. Avoid long sessions on concrete or asphalt until your feet are broken in. The diverse textures of natural surfaces also engage foot muscles more than flat hard surfaces.
Pay attention to body signals
A little muscle soreness is to be expected, but shooting pains or persistent pain indicates you must back down. Pay attention to:
- Fatigued arches (can signal weak foot muscles)
- Sore calf muscles (normal when changing gait)
- Aching joints (possibly that you’re going too fast)
Have an old-fashioned pair of shoes available for days when your feet are worn out.
Consider Custom Inserts
If you’re struggling with the lack of arch support, try thin, flexible inserts just for the transition period. Look for ones made from natural materials that don’t compromise the shoe’s flexibility. Gradually reduce insert thickness as your feet strengthen.
Maintain Your Foot Health
Regular foot care makes barefoot shoes more comfortable:
- Massage your feet with a golf ball or roller
- Stretch your plantar fascia and calves daily
- Soak sore feet in Epsom salts
- Trim toenails properly
Dress for the Conditions
Barefoot shoes are minimally insulated. In cool weather, wear thermal socks or seek insulated minimalist styles. In wet weather, wear water-resistant models or apply a waterproof coating to leather models.
Read our article What Running Shoes Good For Flat Feet?
Conclusion
Barefoot shoes provide an excellent compromise for barefoot movement but are not suitable for all feet. Certain users have stronger feet and more flexibility, and others end up with pain, injury, and inconvenience. It’s truly all about gradual transition, proper strengthening of your feet, and realistic self-assessment of your needs.
If you’re looking at minimalist shoes, transition slowly, listen to your body, and don’t rush the process. A hybrid strategy switching between barefoot shoes and supportive shoes may work for some individuals. Keep in mind: what is ideal for one set of feet may not be right for yours. See a podiatrist or movement specialist so that they can advise you to make an informed decision based on the shape of your feet and your way of life.
FAQs
Q: How long will it take to acclimatize to barefoot shoes?
A: It takes most to acclimatize at the most basic level in 3-6 months, and it takes a year to be fully acclimatized. Wear them for shorter durations (30-60 minutes daily) and then build up.
Q: Will barefoot shoes treat flat feet?
A: They might help make the foot muscles stronger, yet some flat-footed people dislike wearing them as they are not comfortable with or without arch support. Proceed carefully and consult a specialist if in doubt.
Q: Are barefoot shoes suitable for running?
A: Yes, but only after the body has adapted. Abrupt transitioning from cushioned running shoes heightens the chances of injury. Emphasize form and begin running short distances.
Q: Why do my calves ache when I walk barefoot in shoes?
A: This is to be expected because your gait shifts to a more forefoot/midfoot strike. Calf muscles contract more initially. Shorten wear time and get frequent calf stretching.
Q: Do I wear barefoot shoes at work?
A: It is based on your line of work. They could be okay for office use but not necessarily okay for construction, medical, or other professions that demand protection footwear.
Q: Do podiatrists recommend barefoot shoes?
A: It is up to individual choice. Some suggest them for certain conditions, but others don’t suggest them, particularly for individuals with existing foot issues. Seek professional advice.
Q: Can barefoot shoes be worn by children?
A: Some professionals opine that they promote natural foot growth but have a good fit and check for the absence of irritation or change of gait.
Q: How can I determine whether my barefoot shoes fit well?
A: Your toes should be able to spread normally without being stuffed, and there should be approximately a thumb’s width of space further on than your longest toe. The heel should not slip.
Q: Must I wear orthotics in barefoot shoes?
A: Most minimalist footwear is not accommodative to standard orthotics. Some use thin, flexible inserts as a transition tool, but this negates some of the benefits you’re seeking.
Q: Why are my feet tired in barefoot shoes?
A: This should be expected at first as your foot muscles are exerting themselves more. Restrict wear time and incorporate foot-strengthening exercises to establish endurance.
